In Quebec, Canada, Mohammad Shafia, his
wife, Tooba, and his son, Hamed, were, fortunately, found guilty
of the "Honor (Religious/Cultural) Killing"
murders of Shafia's three daughters and first wife. Some call it
"Honor Killing;"some call it other names, but Islamic
governments fancy the term "Stoning to Death." Some
downplay the phenomenon, ignore the pre-meditation element in the
crime and call it "Domestic Violence." Whatever it is
called, it is a "MURDER."
This form of "MURDER" is sadly
being debated as to whether it is cultural or religious as though
it would make a difference and make the "MURDER" less horrific.
On a recent CNN interview with Solidad O'Brian, Irshad Manji,
Director of the Moral Courage Project, in NY, and author of "Allah,
Liberty and Love," in her effort to protect faith, made a
failed attempt to ensure viewers that it is a cultural not a
religious phenomenon, as though it mattered.
Whether the villain is a Moslem, Jew,
Christian, Buddhist, atheist or whatever, murder is murder be it
for cultural or religious reasons. Strangely enough, this, and the
frequent murder of girls and women, happens habitually in Islamic
cultures. Murder can neither be tolerated nor accepted even if an
invisible mighty god orders it.
It was demoralizing and daunting to
hear the self-proclaimed intellectual Saudi Ambassador to London,
Ghazi Al-Qusaibi, say that "...Stoning may seem irrational to
the western mind, but it is at the core of the Islamic faith."
A semi-educated earthling, the Saudi ambassador to England
asserted that stoning adulterers to death is a legitimate
punishment for society. He also said that Westerners should
respect Muslim culture on this matter. Here is the dilemma;
are we, in the democratic West, to tolerate and respect the
intolerable and disrespectable?
Certainly, we could tolerate and
respect people's beliefs; however, what if, not in this writer's
views, but in consideration of basic humanity and human decency,
such beliefs are criminal in nature, uncivilized in foundation,
and immoral at the core? Should we tolerate and respect Mormons'
practice of marrying underage girls, and marry many of them?
Should we tolerate and respect the KKK practice of burning blacks
at the cross? Should we tolerate and respect insane Christians who
burn abortion clinics killing doctors and nurses? Should we
tolerate and respect Christians who want to wipe out Muslims?
Should we tolerate and respect Muslims eager to wipe out all
infidels, non-believers in Islam? Should we have tolerated and
respected Hitler? Mr. Saudi Ambassador, why not?
Many are up in arms defending religion,
testifying and swearing that religion does not say this or that or
insisting religion is innocent. They claim it is culture. Whether
culture or religion, should we tolerate and respect such behavior
in the name of tolerance? Will accepting and respecting such